4-8 July 2016
Kramer Law building
Africa/Johannesburg timezone
<a href="http://events.saip.org.za/internalPage.py?pageId=10&confId=86">The Proceedings of SAIP2016</a> published on 24 December 2017

Teaching problem-solving by means of shoestring experiments

8 Jul 2016, 11:10
20m
2B (Kramer Law building)

2B

Kramer Law building

UCT Middle Campus Cape Town
Oral Presentation Track E - Physics Education Physics Education

Speaker

Prof. Deena Naidoo (School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand)

Main supervisor (name and email)<br>and his / her institution

N/A

Level for award<br>&nbsp;(Hons, MSc, <br> &nbsp; PhD, N/A)?

N/A

Apply to be<br> considered for a student <br> &nbsp; award (Yes / No)?

No

Would you like to <br> submit a short paper <br> for the Conference <br> Proceedings (Yes / No)?

Yes

Please indicate whether<br>this abstract may be<br>published online<br>(Yes / No)

Yes

Abstract content <br> &nbsp; (Max 300 words)<br><a href="http://events.saip.org.za/getFile.py/access?resId=0&materialId=0&confId=34" target="_blank">Formatting &<br>Special chars</a>

Traditional “recipe-based” practical exercises may have a high degree of outcome predictability, but, because they absolve the student of a great deal of thinking, such exercises have a low degree of value as learning experiences. Practical exercises could instead become problem solving activities, where the student must devise a method as well as generate an answer to a question. The student is given prior warning only of the broad outcome of the task. A common objection to this sort of exercises is that realistically, it can only be performed by students after the relevant ‘theory’ has been covered. This can present a difficulty for service courses where prohibitively large groups of students would have to perform the same practical exercise simultaneously. In addition, economic and logistic obstacles such as the cost of purchasing large quantities of laboratory equipment, and problems of storage can be seen as prohibitive. In this paper, two exercises are presented that are potentially good learning experiences and can easily be performed by first year Physics students without detailed procedural instructions as problem solving activities compared to traditional ‘cookbook’ practical exercises. Furthermore, the apparatus for these exercises is cheap to acquire and relatively easy to store, hence the objection mentioned above becomes invalid.

Primary author

Mr Douglas Clerk (School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand)

Co-authors

Dr Claudia Albers (WITS university) Prof. Deena Naidoo (School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand)

Presentation Materials

There are no materials yet.

Peer reviewing

Paper